Sign In - Sign up  
TOP 10 LISTS     SHOPPING DEALS     POPULAR NEWS    WHO IS MSM?     HELP
Top 10 Most Annoying American Idols   by mrsockmonkey
Home > Top 10 Lists > Most Annoying American Idols
Of the Top 10 Most Annoying American Idols,
Which do you think is #1?
  Justin Guarini
  Paris Bennett
  Clay Aiken
  Mikalah Gordon
  Nikki McKibbin
  Brenna Gethers
  Constantine Maroulis
  Kellie Pickler
  Scott Savol
  Sanjaya Malakar


The Top 10 Most Annoying American Idols
View rankings


Nikki McKibbin
Remember this girl? The dyed-hair single-mom who somehow made it into the top three, but yet, didn't hit a single note the entire season. By the time she reached the upper echelons of the show, there was genuine concern that she might somehow sneak into the top two, what with Justin and Kelly canceling out each other's votes, or something like that. Luckily, she was soon voted out of the Idol world, and unlike the other semi-finalists from other years, has not been seen since.


Scott Savol
Scott isn't on the list because he's ugly and fat (not that he isn't either of the two) - he's on here because his arrogance far exceeds his talent. He laughed when Constantine got kicked off the show (when everyone knew it should have been him), and continued to talk back to the judges everytime they gave him rightly earned criticism.


Kellie Pickler
The first time Kellie appeared in the auditions, people became teary eyed listening to her life story about her imprisoned father and dead-beat mom. But after a few weeks of laying on the 'I ain't never been nowhere and don't know nothing but I'm as shiny as a shrimp in grits to be here and swim in your see-ment pond!' act, people stopped buying it. And her post-show boob job only makes her innocent little farm girl act even less believeable. Plus, she is definitely NOT smarter than a 5th grader!


Sanjaya Malakar
Out of all the annoying contestants, at least Sanjaya gets props for using it to his advantage. He knew he couldn't sing, and would definitely be voted off asap, unless he did something different... so he decided to be as annoying as possible. Each week he put on a stupid hairdo and gave (purposely?) the worst rendition of each song possible. Finally, Simon just couldn't take it anymore and gave him the "that was utterly horrendous" speech.


Clay Aiken
Like most of the annoying finalists on Idol, people either loved Clay or hated him. No doubt, the kid could sing. And no doubt, he's done terrifically in his post-Idol career. But at the same time, his sappy, histrionic, Broadway voice mixed with his ardent, ravenous fans just made him intolerable. The thousands of obsessive, screaming 12 year olds holding signs saying "Aikin' for Clay" was just too much to handle.


Mikalah Gordon
Mikalah didn't last long, but she sure made her mark. Somewhere along the way, poor Mikalah thought it would be hilarious to revive Fran Drescher's schtick for a new generation. Yet for some reason, the judges seemed to absolutely love her, while the audience hated her. After she was eliminated, she later returned for cameo appearances, this time sporting the full Lawng Island makeover: crazy highlights, a fake tan, and loads of makeup. Awful.


Constantine Maroulis
Constantine was cocky, ugly, and not fit for popstardom. (Paula had a crush on him, but that just goes to show how she has very questionable taste in men.) Plus, he called himself a rocker, which kind of ran contradictory to his Broadway training in Rent. Everything about him screamed poser, and to this day, we still don't know why there are Connie fans absolutely devoted to him. He's awful. Truly, truly awful.


Brenna Gethers
Some people may not know her, since Brenna did not make it past the top 12 girls into the Top 12 finalist on Season 5, but it really says something about how people can find her so annoying in such little time. She had all the attitude of a diva, with only a small fraction (if any) of the talent. After being voted off the show, she hinted at a possible return to the show stating “Actually, the secret rumor is that they’re going to ask me to come back on the show and I’m going to win the whole thing. Keep watching. Stay tuned. “ As if.


Paris Bennett
Paris had an amazing set of pipes on her. She also was cute as a button. And she also was crazy annoying. From her quiet air of entitlement or her so-precious-it-hurts princess voice, Paris became surprisingly grating as the season went on. She was an early favorite to go far, and she did, but her yo-yoing between cutie Princess Pea and wannabe Beyoncé drove everyone mad. Yech.


Justin Guarini
The original sucker. Justin Guarini started off season one as the guy to beat. The judges loved him. The girls loved him. And the guys, well, they hated him (but guys didn't count for much that first season). Somewhere along the way, however, the anti-Justin movement grew stronger - his silly Side-Show Bob hair and strange dancing/bopping became too much for people to take.

 



American Idol Message Board
Post Comment
2007-12-28 18:48:33 Posted by kelliecrazy77

OMG! Kellie Pickler SHOULD NOT even be in this poll! She is beautiful, talented and such a good person! Don't believe me? Go here.... http://www.myspace.com/kelliepickler

   
FIRST PREV ( Page 1 of 1 ) NEXT LAST


News about American Idol
View all American Idol news
    Syesha Mercado | ShAĆ© - ShAĆ©'s Blog

    Syesha Mercado may have come in third place in the "American Idol" competition, but she is definitely living her life as a winner.



    'Idols' on the road

    It's been more than six weeks since Season 7 of "American Idol" wrapped, with rocker David Cook - in what some dubbed a shocker - taking the title over teen crooner David Archuleta.



    American Idol's Live Tour 2008

    exclusive review and pix!!



    American Idol: Season 6 Finale Performance Show - The Top 2

    Rent It Review:When "American Idol" hit the airwaves in 2002, it was the biggest reality TV hit in years, even managing to bring Paula Abdul back into pop culture for the first time since she danced with MC Skat Kat in 1989. The series even managed to get past the legendary stumble of "From Justin to K



    American Idol Season 8 Auditions Begin

    Yes it is gonna begin...schedule is give here



    Game makers eye young girls with ''Boogie SuperStar''

    f ''American Idol'' and a modern fairy tale combined to create a video game, you'd get ''Boogie SuperStar'' -- Electronic Art's latest game for the Nintendo Wii system. But instead of finding Prince...






Other Top 10 Lists

Featured
  • Contestants on A Shot at Love 2 with Tila Tequila
  • Hottest Male TV Doctor
  • Most Annoying American Idols
  • Hottest Asian Women
  • American Idol 7 Top 12


  • Most Popular
  • Hottest Women in Country Music
  • Hottest Female American Idols
  • Best American Idol Contestants
  • Contestants on A Shot at Love with Tila Tequila
  • Dumbest Celebrity Quotes
  • Hottest Blonde Actresses


  • Newest
  • Contestants on A Shot at Love 2 with Tila Tequila
  • American Idol 7 Top 12
  • Favorite Female Rising Stars of 2007
  • Sexiest Full Figured Women
  • Hottest Actors Over 50
  • Hottest Lost Characters


  • Browse all





    All Topics
  • Hottest Blonde Actresses
  • Sexiest Full Figured Women
  • Contestants on A Shot at Love 2 with Tila Tequila
  • Pictures Where George Bush Looks Like a Monkey
  • Best American Idol Contestants
  • Celebrities that Deserve to be in Jail
  • Most Shocking Britney Spears Moments
  • Dancing With the Stars Season 5 Stars
  • Hottest Eva Longoria Maxim Picture
  • Most Annoying American Idols
  • Contestants on A Shot at Love with Tila Tequila
  • American Idol 7 Top 12
  • Dumbest Beauty Pageant Answers
  • Favorite Desperate Housewives Characters
  • Best American Idol Performances
  • Favorite Girls on America's Next Top Model
  • American Idol Season 7 Guys Top 12
  • Sluttiest Celebrities
  • Stupidest Fads
  • Unsexy Women Who Try to be Sexy
  • American Idol Season 7 Girls Top 12
  • Hottest Asian Women
  • Sluttiest TV Characters
  • Hottest Women in Country Music
  • Hottest Male on Desperate Housewives
  • Hottest Female American Idols
  • America's Next Top Model Season 9 Girls
  • Survivor China Season 15
  • Slutty Halloween Costumes
  • Ugliest Celebrities Without Makeup
  • Bachorlettes on the Bachelor Season 11
  • Hottest Male TV Doctor
  • Best Shopping Deals Sites
  • Hottest Men in Sex in the City
  • Hottest Women Tony Soprano Slept With
  • Hottest Actors Over 50
  • Favorite Female Rising Stars of 2007
  • Best Halloween Costumes
  • Hottest Women Alan Shore Slept With on Boston Legal
  • Bad Celebrity Mothers
  • Dumbest Celebrity Quotes
  • Best Celebrity Halloween Costumes
  • Celebrities That are Too Skinny
  • Hottest Lost Characters


  • Related Topics
  • Kimberly Caldwell
  • Tila Tequila
  • A Shot At Love
  • Hell's Kitchen
  • Bachelorette
  • America's Got Talent
  • Kim Kardashian
  • Hannah Montana
  • So You Think You Can Dance
  • David Cook
  • iCarly
  • Ben 10
  • Beverly Hills 90210
  • Good Morning America
  • Camp Rock
  • Beverly Hills 90210
  • America's Got Talent
  • A Shot At Love
  • Erin Andrews
  • Tila Tequila
  • Cat Deeley
  • Shear Genius
  • The Real World
  • House Of Payne
  • So You Think You Can Dance
  • Ghost Hunters
  • Kari Byron
  • Project Runway
  • Super Nanny
  • Espn News




  •  



    Contact Mr. Sock Monkey: msm@mrsockmonkey.com   |    Site map